Contact Us

8 Questions to Ask When Deciding Between a Self-Hosted or Cloud-Based LMS

Deciding on a Learning Management System (LMS) is a big step for any organization. Whether you’re rolling out training for employees, customers, or partners, choosing between a self-hosted and a cloud-based LMS will shape your experience for years to come. Before making a decision, consider these key questions to ensure you choose the right fit.

 
1. What Are Our Organization’s Security and Compliance Requirements?

Security and compliance are critical considerations, especially for organizations handling sensitive data. Your choice of LMS should align with regulatory requirements and internal security policies.

    • Highly regulated industries (healthcare, finance, government) often have strict compliance needs.
    • Self-hosted LMS solutions provide more control over security and data storage.
    • Cloud-based LMS providers offer security certifications (ISO 27001, SOC 2) and handle compliance updates.

Blue cloud with a lock on it that is blocking incoming data. Caption reads: "Standard cloud security will be fed into your system, but you still have enough autonomy that access is on a need-to-know basis. Nobody at your vendor’s headquarters has access to your files unless you specifically provide it. At the same time, you can use cloud security features. These features aren’t available to companies with their own physical servers." -Christopher Pappas, Founder, eLearning Industry

 
2. What Level of IT Support Can We Provide?

Managing an LMS requires ongoing technical support. The level of IT resources available within your organization will influence whether a self-hosted or cloud-based solution is a better fit.

  • Self-hosted LMS requires in-house IT teams for server maintenance, troubleshooting, and updates.
  • Cloud-based LMS reduces the IT burden by offering hosting, automatic updates, and support.
 
3. How Scalable Does Our LMS Need to Be?

As your organization grows, so will your LMS needs. Consider whether your chosen system can seamlessly accommodate increasing users and evolving training programs.

  • Cloud-based LMS platforms scale easily with demand.
  • Self-hosted LMS requires capacity planning and infrastructure adjustments.
 
4. What Is Our Budget?

Budget constraints can play a significant role in determining the right LMS. It’s important to assess both initial investments and long-term costs.

    • Self-hosted LMS involves high upfront costs for infrastructure and maintenance.
    • Cloud-based LMS follows a subscription model, spreading costs over time.

Person sitting in a wheelchair while looking at a screen full of people on computer monitor. Caption reads: "One major advantage of using a self-hosted LMS is the ability to customize it according to your specific needs and preferences. Institutions can tailor features and incorporate tools to create a distinct learning platform aimed at achieving particular educational objectives and teaching practices." -St. Vincent Times

 
5. How Customizable Does Our LMS Need to Be?

Customization allows organizations to tailor the LMS to their specific needs, but not all platforms offer the same level of flexibility.

  • Self-hosted LMS offers deep customization, including branding and integrations.
  • Cloud-based LMS has some customization limits but provides APIs and third-party integrations.
 
6. How Quickly Do We Need to Implement the LMS?

Implementation timelines can vary significantly between LMS solutions. If you need a quick deployment, certain options may be more suitable.

  • Cloud-based LMS allows for faster implementation with pre-configured infrastructure.
  • Self-hosted LMS can take weeks or months to configure, depending on complexity.
 
7. What Is Our Disaster Recovery and Backup Plan?

Unexpected technical failures can disrupt learning operations. A solid backup and recovery strategy ensures minimal downtime and data loss.

    • Self-hosted LMS requires a strong disaster recovery and backup strategy.
    • Cloud-based LMS providers typically handle backups and ensure minimal downtime.

Person sitting working on two computers and a mobile phone in an office. Caption reads: "Before finalizing your decision, take advantage of demos or trial periods offered by vendors. Testing the LMS will provide insight into its user interface, support services, and overall functionality. Involve actual end users in the testing phase to ensure the platform meets practical needs and expectations. Observing how real users interact with the system can help you avoid potential pitfalls and make an informed decision." -Paradiso

 
8. What Kind of User Experience Do We Want to Offer?

A well-designed LMS enhances learner engagement and adoption. Consider how frequently updates and improvements will be available.

  • Cloud-based LMS providers frequently update platforms to improve usability.
  • Self-hosted LMS requires continuous development efforts to enhance user experience.
 
Scenario 1: Cloud-Based LMS – Horizon Electronics (Consumer Electronics Manufacturing)

As Horizon Electronics expanded its global footprint, the company recognized the need for a scalable, cost-effective training solution to support its diverse workforce. With employees spread across multiple regions, they required an LMS that could be quickly deployed, easily maintained, and accessible from anywhere. A cloud-based LMS emerged as the ideal choice, providing the flexibility, security, and efficiency necessary to keep their teams trained and compliant.

Robotic machine working on electronics in a factory. Caption reads: “Horizon Electronics. Industry: Consumer Electronics Manufacturing. Company Size: 800 employees worldwide. Why they chose a cloud-based LMS: Scalability: Needed an LMS that could grow with the company and handle a global workforce. Budget-friendly: Subscription model suited their financial structure. Low IT burden: Reduced internal IT support requirements with cloud hosting. Security compliance: Cloud provider offered certifications (ISO 27001, SOC 2). Quick implementation: Rolled out training programs within 2 months. Outcome: Global deployment with increased engagement and seamless scaling. Reduced downtime and better user experience.”

 
Scenario 2: Self-Hosted LMS – MedSecure Health Systems (Healthcare Technology)

As MedSecure Health Systems prioritized data security and compliance in the healthcare technology sector, the company sought a learning management system (LMS) that offered full control over its sensitive training data. With strict HIPAA regulations to meet, a self-hosted LMS provided the security oversight needed to safeguard patient and employee information. Beyond compliance, MedSecure required a deeply integrated and customizable training platform to align with its internal workflows. Leveraging its in-house IT team, the company managed infrastructure and maintenance, ensuring seamless system updates and security enhancements. Over time, this approach delivered significant cost savings compared to cloud-based alternatives while enabling flexible, tailored training programs that met evolving regulatory requirements.

Surgeons looking at digital readouts. Caption reads: "Company: MedSecure Health Systems. Industry: Healthcare Technology. Company Size: 350 employees. Why they chose a self-hosted LMS: Security control: Required full control over data and compliance (HIPAA). Customization: Needed deep integration and tailored training solutions. IT support: In-house IT team managed infrastructure and maintenance. Long-term cost savings: Lower ongoing fees compared to cloud-based options. Outcome: Custom training programs that met compliance standards. High flexibility with internal control over system updates and security."

 
The Verdict? It Depends on Your Priorities

Choosing between a self-hosted and cloud-based LMS depends on your organization’s needs:

    • Choose self-hosted if security, customization, and control are top priorities.
    • Choose cloud-based if ease of use, scalability, and low maintenance are more important.

By evaluating these key factors, organizational leaders can make an informed decision that aligns with business goals, technical capabilities, and budget. The right LMS should empower your team, streamline learning, and support your organization’s growth.

 
Related blogs

Transform Your Training Programs with an AI-Enhanced LMS

Best Practices for Collaboration Between Outsourced Instructional Designers and Teachers

The Anti-Trend Trend: Why Instructional Design in 2025 is About Results, Not Razzle-Dazzle

 
References

“Hosted LMS vs. Self-Hosted LMS: Which Is Right for Your?” St. Vincent Times. 1/20/25. Accessed 3/13/25. https://www.stvincenttimes.com/hosted-lms-vs-self-hosted-lms-which-is-right-for-you 

Pappas, Christopher. “3 Pros and Cons of Investing in a Self-Hosted Cloud-Based LMS.” eLearning Industry. 5/13/24. Accessed 3/13/25. https://elearningindustry.com/pros-cons-investing-self-hosted-cloud-based-lms 

“What is a Hosted LMS and Why Do You Need It?” Paradiso. Accessed 3/13/25. https://www.paradisosolutions.com/blog/what-is-a-hosted-lms-and-why-do-you-need-it 

MATC_Logo

+1 (267) 368-7090
contact@matcgroup.com

Powered by MATC Group Inc  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.