Why Your Subject Matter Experts Are Burned Out (and How to Help)

Your subject matter experts are probably good at their jobs. Unfortunately, that may be exactly why everyone keeps interrupting them.

They are the people who know why the process works that way, where the exception lives, which policy version is current, and why the quick fix may create three new problems by Thursday. They answer questions, review documents, train new employees, solve escalations—and still have their own work to complete.

By November and December, that pressure often grows. Year-end deadlines, budget planning, employee vacations, customer demands, and holiday obligations compete for the same limited time and energy. SHRM notes that shortened work months and year-end deadlines can intensify workplace stress during the holiday season.

Quote card reading, “Burn-out is a syndrome conceptualized as resulting from chronic workplace stress that has not been successfully managed.” — World Health Organization

Burnout Does Not Always Look Dramatic

Burnout is not always someone announcing they have reached their limit before dramatically closing a laptop.

For SMEs, it may look like slower responses, shorter answers, missed meetings, reluctance to volunteer, or an ever-growing list of “I’ll get to that after this deadline” tasks.

Watch for signs such as:

  • Repeated interruptions that prevent focused work
  • A growing queue of reviews, approvals, and “quick questions”
  • Frustration with questions that have already been answered somewhere
  • Delays in updating critical procedures because urgent work always comes first
  • Increasing reliance on one person for routine decisions
  • Less interest in mentoring, improving processes, or contributing ideas

These signs do not automatically mean someone is burned out. They may mean the organization has created a role that is carrying too much invisible work.

Gallup’s 2026 workplace research found that 40% of employees globally experienced significant stress the previous day. Organizations cannot eliminate every source of stress, especially at year-end. But they can stop adding avoidable friction to the people they rely on most.

The “Ask Dave” System Has a Cost

Every organization has a Dave.

Dave knows the workaround. Dave understands the legacy system. Dave can explain the exception that is not in the procedure because nobody has had time to update it. Dave is helpful, dependable, and one message away from becoming the organization’s unofficial search engine.

That helps in the moment. It is also a bottleneck.

As we discussed in Every Organization Has a Dave (Until Dave Retires), knowledge that lives primarily with one person creates risk for everyone—including Dave.

What Employers Can Do Now

You do not need a 14-month transformation plan in December. Start with a few practical steps:

  • Protect expert time. Give SMEs uninterrupted blocks for priority work, reviews, or documentation. Treat those blocks as real commitments.
  • Find the repeat questions. Ask SMEs what they answer most often. Turn those answers into a short FAQ, checklist, decision tree, or job aid.
  • Capture knowledge in small pieces. Do not ask an overwhelmed SME to document everything. Start with one high-value process, recurring exception, or decision point.
  • Share the load. Pair SMEs with a writer, instructional designer, or trained colleague who can organize information and draft content. SMEs should validate expertise, not carry the entire documentation project.
  • Cross-train others. Identify people who can handle common questions and lower-risk decisions before the SME’s calendar—or patience—reaches capacity.

 

Knowledge as a Product explores the larger principle: information is valuable only when people can find, understand, trust, and use it.

Quote card reading, “Your most helpful expert is not an unlimited resource.”

 

The Goal Is Not More Heroics

A responsive SME can look like someone with extra capacity. Usually, they are someone who has become very good at fitting urgent requests into an already-full day.

The end of the year is a good time to ask: Where are we depending on individual heroics when a clearer process, better resource, or shared knowledge system would do?

Helping SMEs is not about asking less of them. It is about making sure their expertise can help more people without requiring them to answer the same question 17 times this month.

How MATC Can Help

MATC helps organizations capture critical expertise, reduce knowledge bottlenecks, improve documentation, and build learning and performance-support resources that help employees work more independently.

When your SMEs are overwhelmed, the solution is rarely to ask them to work harder. It is to make the knowledge they already provide easier for others to find and use.

 
Related Blogs

Every Organization Has a Dave (Until Dave Retires)

Knowledge as a Product: How to Design Information People Will Actually Use

The Graveyard of Unread PDFs: Why Documentation Fails and How to Fix It

 
References

Myer, Kathryn. “How to Help Employees During the Stressful Holiday Season.” SHRM. 1/10/24. Accessed 10/8/26. https://www.shrm.org/topics-tools/news/benefits-compensation/how-to-help-employees-during-the-stressful-holiday-season 

“State of the Global Workplace 2026.” Gallup. April 2026. Accessed 10/8/26. https://www.gallup.com/workplace/697904/state-of-the-global-workplace-global-data.aspx 

 
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.